The bakery is nestled on the Upper West Side in a busy area that consists of Jacques Torres, Alice's Tea Cup, and Magnolia Bakery, to name a few, so there are many options to choose from. But, anybody in their right mind would rush past all the other options without even looking back and head straight for Levain. They sell a lot of freshly baked bread items, but are most known for their monstrous cookies. The owners created these cookies when they were training for the Ironman and needed a calorie/energy bomb to counteract the grueling workouts, and they hit the jackpot with these cookies.
When you first see them in the display case, you are in disbelief at the size of the cookie. They look like huge scones, but way better. You have four options to choose from: Chocolate Chip Walnut, Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip and Oatmeal Raisin. Each one of the cookies is about a pound in weight (I have read that they are 6oz, but they feel like a pound to me) so they are not for the faint of heart. I have tried all flavors besides the Oatmeal Raisin, because even though I hear that the oatmeal raisin is amazing, I can't imagine making the trip there and not getting something with chocolate. My favorite flavor, and the one I always order, is the Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip, which is a chocolate lovers dream. No matter what time of day you get there, the cookie is always served to you warm and fresh with the chips oozing.
After craving these cookies for weeks and dreaming about them, I finally made my trip to the bakery today and ordered the Dark Chocolate Chocolate Chip. Once it was handed to me, I split the cookie opened and was immediately overcome with the strong scent of chocolatey, buttery goodness. Then, I looked down at the cookie and saw the oozing chocolate chips and the almost raw (in a good way) cookie center.
I took my first bite, and was in heaven. The outside of the cookie has a nice crisp shell which works well with the soft gooey center and the melted chips. I don't know how they get the chips to stay melted for so long, but it is just part of the magic of these cookies that can not be replicated anywhere else (in fact, I got my cookie about 5 hours ago and some of the chips are STILL melted). You get a mouthful of chips in every bite, and the dark chocolate flavor is outstanding. It is hard to put into words how amazing this cookie is (though I am clearly trying), but all I can say is that it is life changing. While some could argue that it is more like a cross between a brownie and a cookie, I would take this over any other cookie any day. While I had to limit myself to only eating half because I can't really rationalize eating an 8oz cookie, no matter how hard I worked out this morning, it was worth every last bite and calorie.
This isn't my first visit here, so I have gotten the chance to try their other flavors as well. The chocolate chip walnut is also amazing and is more of the traditional chocolate chip cookie. Even though they do get some grief occasionally for having walnuts instead of a traditional chocolate chip cookie, trust me you barely even taste them and it is SO worth it. The dark chocolate peanut butter chip is also out of this world, and is a must for any peanut butter lover. That being said, I will always stay true to my dark chocolate chip cookie and have to order that one every time I go.
Lucky for me (health wise) I have to go out of my way to go to Levain, so I don't frequent here too often, which makes my occasional visits that much more special. But, if you are in NYC visiting (even if just for a day) you MUST make the trip to Levain, even if it is out of your way. Trust me, it will be worth it. And, they also ship their cookies so you can get them no matter where you live! Even though they won't be warm or oozing when they get to you, they will still be just as delicious.
